FREE SHIPPING EVERY DAY Order within 8 hours and 30 minutes to ship today

Sign In to Earn Rewards

SIGN IN For Best Experience

Earn 3% in Rewards Credit for every dollar you spend.
Convenient Tracking
Speedier Checkout

Sign In Create Account

Sort

FILTERS (5) 11 FOUND Reset Done

- Right 55 matching results
- Left 11 matching results
- 9"
- 10"
- 10.50"
- 11.50"
- 11.75"
- 12"
- 12.25"
- 12.50"
- 12.75"
- 13"
- 13.50"
- 14"
- 15"
- 30"
- 31"
- 31.50"
- 32"
- 32.50"
- 33"
- 33.50"
- 34"

Coming Soon

Left 12.25" 34.00" Catcher First Base

11 FOUND

Left 12.25" 34.00" Catcher First Base CLEAR ALL

Popular Latest Avg. Rating Savings $: Low to High $: High to Low

Angled front view of a black first base mitt with Rawlings and GAMER SERIES embossed on the palm, featuring a deep pocket and intricate lacing.

Rawlings Gamer ContoUR 12.25" Youth First Base Mitt: GDCTU-10B ^$149^.95 $169.95 1

Wilson A2K SuperSkin 2820 12.25" Baseball First Base Mitt: WBW1000721225 ^$329^.95 $449.95 11

Shoeless Joe Professional 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: 3400CM ^$199^.95 Used from $159.95 55

All Star PHX Paige Halstead 34" Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: CMW-PHX-34 ^$299^.95 1

Front view of a black Rawlings NXT glove with mint green lacing and white stitching.

Rawlings NXT 12.25'' Baseball First Base Mitt: NXTDCTU-10BM ^$179^.99

Mizuno MVP Prime 34" Fastpitch Catcher's Mitt: GXS50PF3 ^$129^.95 4

Shoeless Jane Professional 34" Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: 3400FPCM ^$199^.95 Used from $179.95 2

Rawlings Heart of the Hide 12.25" Baseball First Base Mitt: PRORDCTU-10PCB ^$329^.99

Angled top-down view of two black catchers mitts with white lacing and deep pockets.

Shoeless Joe Double Play 34" Baseball Catcher's Mitt: BK-GY3400CM ^$199^.95

Close-up of two pink baseball gloves with light blue lacing, one interior showing "PROFESSIONAL COLLECTION" and an orange heart with "BE ME".

Easton Professional Collection 34'' Jen Schroeder Fastpitch Softball Catcher's Mitt: RUDI-3.0 ^$329^.99

Shoeless Joe Golden Age Series Catcher's Mitt: 1915CML ^$149^.95 1

Put Our Expertise to Work

We know gloves - and we’re here to help you find the perfect fit. Get the right one for your game with these resources:

Sizing Guide

Determine the right size glove for you or your player

Glove Coach

Get just-for-you glove recommendations

Resource Guide

Find helpful information written by our roster of Experts

support@justgloves.com

4.9 Star Rating, Google Customer Reviews